Puffing Billy vs. Wine Tours: Can You Actually Do Both in One Day?

Puffing Billy vs Wine Tours – Can you actually squeeze both in one day?
That question usually lands in my inbox from travellers still reeling from a big night in the Melbourne CBD, coffee still in their mugs, Google Maps open and ready to go. They’re trying to work out whether a ride on a heritage steam train and a decent glass of Yarra Valley pinot can both fit into their daylight hours without blowing their schedule. The short answer? Yes – but only if you plan it carefully & don’t get your hopes up
Hi, I’m Paul Beames – I’ve been showing visitors around Victoria for long enough to have seen days fall to pieces. This particular combo – Puffing Billy in the Dandenongs alongside a Yarra Valley afternoon of wine tastings – can either be a real hoot or leave you frazzled. It all comes down to how you plan your day, get from A to B & know what to leave out.

The One-Day Reality Check

Packing two of Victoria’s most popular attractions into a single day will always require some compromises. You’ve got to work with fixed train timetables, wind through mountain roads, and hope the wineries aren’t too put out by you arriving a bit late. This isn’t a lazy day out, that’s for sure – it’s more of a structured day with very little room for error.

That being said, if you treat Puffing Billy as the morning ‘centrepiece’ and the Yarra Valley as a short, quality-focused afternoon – not some frantic crawl – then it can actually work. I’ve seen guided tours and private day tours handle this combination pretty smoothly, especially if operators like Wildlife Tours are running the show and keeping everything on track.

What the Train Experience Really Involves

The Puffing Billy steam train ride isn’t something you can just casually fit in – it’s a pretty strict schedule that you’ve got to adhere to once you’ve booked your tickets. Most people board at Belgrave or Lakeside Station, then ride through the cool rainforest air over that famous Trestle Bridge and into pretty thick native bushland.

Allow yourself 2 to 3 hours for the whole experience – that’s got to be factored in for parking, getting in the queue, taking some snaps, a quick browse through the gift shop, and just generally soaking up the atmosphere. If you rush this bit, you’ll miss the point of the whole thing.

Emerald Lake Park – Do You Hang Around or Keep Moving?

If you alight at Emerald Lake Park, you’ll find some nice walking tracks, picnic spots and all sorts of birds to look at. It’s all pretty calm and green, and that’s a big part of the Puffing Billy charm. Families love it – people who are short on time and looking to get to the Yarra Valley for lunch usually don’t hang around, though.

My advice? Take a stroll, grab a few photos, top up your water bottle, and then get on with it. The clock is ticking if you want to make it to the wineries without getting stressed.

Crossing From the Dandenongs into Wine Country

Leaving the Dandenong Ranges is a bit of a culture shock – from the damp, fern-filled gullies we’ve grown to love, to the wide open spaces of the farmland. The drive itself is pretty scenic, but it’s a slow burn. Forget about the Princes Freeway, this is the real deal – winding roads that will have your heart in your mouth, cyclists who know the roads like the back of their hand, and the odd Sunday driver who insists on putting on the brakes at every corner.

You’re looking at 75-90 minutes of driving from Lakeside Station to the heart of Yarra Valley wineries. But be warned – that’s only if things are running according to plan. No roadworks, no rain, no detours and definitely no school holidays. If any of those factors come into play, you can kiss goodbye to any semblance of a schedule.

This is where private transport or a well-planned guided tour really starts to pay off. No more guessing, no more wrong turns and certainly no arguments over Google Maps.

What a Yarra Afternoon Can Realistically Look Like

If you’ve caught the Puffing Billy, you’re going to need to rethink your approach to the Yarra Valley. Forget about trying to squeeze in four or five winery stops. Instead, think long lunch, one wine tasting, and that’s it. Don’t try to tick every box – focus on quality over quantity.

You’ve got a few reliable options to choose from:

• Domaine Chandon – great for a glass of bubbly and some top-notch service
• Yering Station – a lot more laid-back, but still a great introduction to the wines and local produce

Many people combine winery tours with a visit to a chocolate factory or a cheese-tasting venue. That way, even if not everyone’s drinking, there’s still something to keep you all entertained.

Self-Drive vs Organised Options – The Brutal Truth

You’ve got a few ways to make this day work:

• If you’re feeling confident on the narrow roads and you’re happy to watch the clock tick by, then self-driving is an option. But let’s be honest, it’s tiring.
• Organised guided tours, on the other hand, are a whole different story. They take the stress away and keep you to a tight schedule. Places like Wildlife Tours are built these days with one thing in mind: avoiding downtime.
• Private day tours sit somewhere in the middle – flexible, comfortable and perfect if you’re staying somewhere central, like the Hotel Windsor near Spring Street in Melbourne.

To be honest, if you’re planning on visiting multiple wineries, self-driving becomes a less appealing option pretty quickly.

Distances People Underestimate Every Time

And now for the part that most itineraries gloss over – the actual driving time.

Route	Typical Travel Time
Melbourne CBD → Puffing Billy Railway	60–70 minutes
Puffing Billy → Yarra Valley	75–90 minutes
Yarra Valley → Melbourne CBD	70–90 minutes

That’s over four hours of travel all in one day – a total killer. Anyone promising otherwise is selling you a pipe dream.

When This Combo Actually Makes Sense — And When It Doesn’t

This combo works a treat if:

• You get a crackin’ early start
• You keep your afternoon winery tour to the bare essentials
• You pre-book every last thing
• You’re okay with a full-on day – no complaints about that

It moves quickly if you’re after a slow lunch, a few tastings, or just can’t stand being stuck to a tight schedule. In that case, break the experiences off into separate chunks. Puffing Billy works a charm on its own, while the Yarra Valley needs a full day – or even an overnight – to give it the respect it deserves.

The Last Word From The Road

Can you cram Puffing Billy and a Yarra Valley afternoon into one crazy day? Yeah, go for it – if you’re smart about it and don’t go turning it into an all-day winery crawl. Treat it as the thoughtful day it can be, rather than just ticking off items on a list. And before you know it, it’s a day you’ll remember rather than one that’s just a jumbled mess.

If you need some help polishing it all off, that’s exactly why my team and I at Wildlife Tours are here – to take the pain out of planning and making the most of your time. And if you’ve managed to come up with a smoother version of this day than the one I’ve put together, I’ve always got room to hear about it – the best itineraries come from sharing, not from glossy maps or mock-ups.

FAQ

Will public transport suffice for this day?

No way – public transport just isn’t going to cut it here. You’ll be stuck hanging around for hours.

Is the steam train just for kids?

No – the heritage, engineering and forest setting are all big hits with adults too – minus the sugar highs, of course.

Can you still fit in Healesville Sanctuary too?

Sorry, no – Healesville Sanctuary needs a whole day on its own if you’re going to get the most out of it – wildlife encounters, native animals, animal education lessons – you name it.

Do wineries accept walk-ins?

Some might, but many won’t, so it’s best to book ahead, especially for seated tastings and lunches.

Is a guided option worth the extra money?

If you value your time, want to relax a bit, and don’t want to be stuck arguing over what to do next, go ahead and invest in it. Especially if you’re trying to pack a lot into one day.